Generally, no. If he’s purring, relaxed, and not hissing, that closed eye is a stamp of approval. You’re a good cat parent.
But if his whole body goes stiff, or he suddenly bites you? That’s a miscommunication. He was saying “stop” and you didn’t catch it.
Consider it a learning moment. Next time, pet the cheek, not the belly. The belly is a trap. It’s always a trap.
The Final Verdict
Your cat closes his eyes when you pet him because he loves you. Or he’s tolerating you. For a cat, that’s basically the same thing.
It means you’ve earned his trust. You are his favorite human (until the neighbor brings out the tuna). Enjoy the moment.
Now go forth, pet your cat, and watch those beautiful eyes close. And if you get a slow blink back? You’ve won at life.
P.S. If your cat doesn’t close his eyes? He’s probably plotting. Sleep with one eye open. You’ve been warned.
