Stop guessing. Stop poking it twenty times. Use a meat thermometer. This little gadget is the hero of every Thanksgiving. It doesn’t lie.
Your target: 165°F in the thickest part of the thigh. Not the breast, not the wing. The thigh. That’s the boss that tells you it’s done. Also check the stuffing—it must hit 165°F too.
Quirky fact: The USDA says stuffing must reach 165°F to kill bacteria. But here’s the funny part—your turkey will continue to cook for about 10 minutes after you pull it out. That’s called carryover cooking. It’s like a free bonus heat wave.
The Terrible, Horrible, No Good Mistake
Do not cook it at 350°F because you’re impatient. You’ll get a burned bird with raw stuffing. That’s a tragedy. A 10-pound stuffed turkey at 350°F might cook faster, but the stuffing will be a cold, dangerous mess.
Also, never stuff it the night before. That’s a bacteria party. Do it right before the oven. Your fridge is for leftovers, not pre-stuffed poultry. Keep it fresh, keep it safe.