Just when you thought the “Will Bates Go to Jail?” storyline was retired, season four brought it back. Anna was raped by a visiting valet, and in a fit of justice-by-murder, Bates killed the guy. Not on purpose—it was an accident during a struggle. Downton Abbey law: if someone around Bates dies, it’s automatically a felony.
This time, Bates didn’t go to prison. Instead, his wife took the fall. Anna was arrested for the murder. And you know what Bates did? He started writing sad letters from his chair again. The cycle of misery was now a family tradition. For two seasons, we watched them whisper through a thick glass window at the prison. It was like a soap opera, but with better costumes.
Joanne Froggatt Says 'Downton Abbey' Originally Wanted an 'Older
The Great Pardon
By season six, the writers must have realized everyone was exhausted. They casually sorted everything out. A witness came forward, and Anna was released. No big speech. No dramatic courtroom scene. Just a “surprise! You’re free now.” Bates blinked twice, hugged his wife, and that was it. The most epic legal drama in television history ended with a whimper.