First up, we have Quinn Finley, a model with a face that screams “I woke up like this” and a vibe that whispers “I’m too cool for this.” They were spotted together in 2017, doing that thing couples do where they look annoyingly perfect in paparazzi photos. It was short-lived, but it taught us one thing: Presley loves a model who can rock a messy bun.
Then came Reese Witherspoon’s daughter, Ava Phillippe. Yes, the spitting image of her mom—like, if you squinted, you’d think you were looking at a time-traveling Elle Woods. They went to prom together in 2018, and the internet exploded. But relax, it was just a friendly date—no tongue-twisting romance. Still, it was the most wholesome power couple since peanut butter and jelly.
And let’s not forget Kacey Montoya, a journalist and TV host who somehow flew under the radar. She’s the “smart and sassy” type, which is refreshing when you’re used to models and heiresses. They dated briefly in 2019, but it fizzled out faster than a mentos in Diet Coke. The takeaway? Presley has range.
Red Flags In Presley Gerber's Dating History
The “Who the Heck Is That?” Level
Now, here’s where it gets wild. There’s a rumor floating around that Presley once dated a mystery girl from a small town in Nebraska. A normal, non-famous human. The horror! Imagine being that perfectly average, then suddenly you’re face-to-face with a Crawford-Gerber at a Taco Bell drive-thru. Did it happen? Probably not. But the internet loves a conspiracy theory.
Then there’s the rumored fling with Sophia Richie—you know, Lionel Richie’s daughter and now Mrs. Elliot Grainge. They were spotted at a party once, and the gossip mill went into overdrive. But it was probably just two famous kids sharing a nacho bowl. Still, the thought of Presley and Sophia as a couple is like imagining a broccoli-flavored ice cream—possible but unnecessary.
Red Flags In Presley Gerber's Dating History
